The one with the ridiculous question

A school friend of mine attended a leading British University to attempt to gain entry to their Medicine course. On being shown into the interview room he was faced by a man who appeared to embody the notion of an academic, right down to the leather patches on his tweed jacket. Before making any form of introduction the interviewer opened a drawer on the desk and put a brick on the table. Addressing my friend he said, “Throw the brick through the window”. My friend looked at him incredulously and mumbled something like, “What?” to which the interviewer simply repeated his original statement. Repeatedly.

My friend, keen to gain admittance to this august institution did as requested and threw the brick through the window, the glass shattering all over the floor and out of the window. He then looked over at the interviewer who asked simply, “Why didn’t you open it first?”. At which point he closed the drawer and made it clear the meeting was over. My friend exited the room a mixture of disappointed and angry and was unsurprised not to be offered a place. For the record he is now a successful surgeon having qualified at a different University.

Why share this recollection? A few years ago I bought a book at an airport. I don’t know what it is about book buying at the airport but it seems to change my criteria or maybe it was just the thought of 13 hours on a plane to China that made me purchase a book entitled “Are you smart enough to work at Google?”. A quick flick through in the departure lounge made it blatantly clear that I am not indeed smart enough to work at Google but I have received positive feedback from those who’ve found it an amusing ‘flick through’ whilst using the bathroom in our home.

Having reflected on the contents of the book I came to the conclusion that as a toilet read it served some considerable value but as an aide to selecting the best candidates it had found its correct place in a toilet… Like many I value the ability of those around me to solve problems but there’s two things I think are important to solving problems: 1. The person must believe the problem is worth solving and 2. They can take some time to solve the problem – the don’t need a solution to hand in an instant.

That said, I have never run a multi-billion dollar business so I was labouring under the illusion that Sergei and Larry et al had a requirement for such outlandish and rapid problem solving in their engineers that us mere mortals couldn’t understand the notion let alone how we would recruit for them. In this I was also wrong…

It turns out my white knight in this case was Sarah Mason who tweeted a link to an article where a ‘high up’ at Google has finally admitted they add no value and they have abandoned them. Hurrah and bravo to Ms. Mason!

So just as Doctors don’t need to open windows before throwing bricks it turns out that Google Engineers don’t need to be able to face ridiculous situations either but to save you a trip to our bathroom here are a few samples of the questions contained in the book:

  1. When there’s a wind blowing, does a round-trip by plane take more time, less time, or the same time?
  2. How would you weigh your head?
  3. You put a glass of water on a record turntable and begin increasing the speed slowly. What will happen first: will the glass slide off, will it tip over, or will the water splash out?

For the record my answers go something like this:

1. That’s not relevant as the availability of exit slots, the pilots determination of speed vs fuel usage and the availability of landing slots at the other end are far more pertinent. As is the availability of Malbec

2. I would apply the equation Force=MassxAcceleration to work out if I moved my head really quickly at the bridge of the nose of the smug person asking this, know the force required to break a nose and accelerate really quickly then I can surely work out the mass of my head

3. You work for Google – try MP3 and leave the turntables to the DJs




Filed under Uncategorized

2 responses to “The one with the ridiculous question

  1. Lydia

    1. Would the wind direction have an impact? *don’t really care*
    2. Presumably by archimedes method and submerge your head in a full-to-the-brim container. If you care about the answer, leave it in there for 5 minutes to be sure.
    3. It would hit the arm!

  2. I’m still too worried about the window pane to contemplate the questions. But if I weighed myself first and then used the shard of glass from the window to cut my head off and wieghed myself and calculate the difference….
    Oh dear, how do I see the weight when my head is on the floor.Oh, yes, through the reflection in the broken window. Hmm??
    Hang on – I’ll google it!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s